Liverpool FC zonal marking - hopefully the last ever blog post

By Neil Macdonald on Sep 20, 09 07:54 PM in Fans

Carragher.egg  on AviaryCarragher.egg on Aviary.

I AM now more than resigned to the fact that whenever Liverpool concede a goal from a dead ball, the usual raft of media pundits will leap upon the zonal marking bandwagon.

"But it doesn't work!" they say. "It's not the English way" "It's too easy to beat" and finally, "It just doesn't work".

It is not so much the criticism I dislike - no team should be above that, despite what Fergie says - it is more the way the perceived wisdom has become accepted fact, regardless of reality.

Because zonal marking took some time to bed in at Anfield, it was identified as a 'problem' and has never shaken off that tag, despite being the system Rafa has used throughout his managerial career, and which has been good enough to help his teams to a raft of silverware.

The reason it is still an issue? Because the media pundits always say it is, relentlessly and religiously, every single time - like in the picture I mocked up. (The same pundits who said the club was in crisis after a below par start to the season - don't get me started on that one)

Never mind the fact that in Rafa's time as manager, Liverpool's record of conceding goals from set pieces is one of the best in the league after a regular hiccup when new players (Glen Johnson, Insua and Kygriakos this time) are bedding in each season.

And never mind there isn't a similar inquest whenever a team that doesn't use zonal marking concedes a goal at a corner or free kick, despite man for man marking's free pass in the media.

Take the West Ham game. Carlton Cole scored a header from a corner with a fantastic leap, despite being surrounded by three defenders. As Rafa said, sometimes you have to say well done, but according to the pundits, it undermined massive weaknesses in the team.

I'll say it again - three defenders were in position to challenge for the ball but were beaten by an attacker who did incredibly well and has developed his game massively this season.

Match of the Day also highlighted Johnson being isolated by drifting back towards his goal at a corner when everyone else went out, leaving three West Ham attackers onside. That's our new signing, who helped to set up the winning goal and is understandably still getting used to Rafa's methods.

They also didn't highlight the end of the clip, where Pepe Reina was clearly reminding him to follow the rest out. And did West ham get anything from the corner? That would be no.

I fully expect Johnson and the other new lads to fit into the system and our wobbles to ease as the season goes on, because they always have.

But I still expect the tiresome zonal marking debate to be wheeled out whenever Liverpool concede a goal, no matter how wrong-headed it is.

Just don't believe the hype - Rafa knows what he is doing.

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Liverpool FC zonal marking - hopefully the last ever blog post. TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.liverpoolbanter.co.uk/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/150572

5 Comments

Mikey said:

I could not agree with you more mate - it really annoys me that man to man marking doesn't get the same treatment in the press. Man to man marking is responsible for many goals each week due to individual error - I'm surprised no pundit ever seems to realise that zonal marking can still be prone to individual errors too.

It needs someone to compare the two pieces with statistics, like Paul Tomkins did a couple of seasons ago. Surprisingly, zonal marking came out better.

Mikmaniac said:

I watched the Manchester Derby today and a few of the goals where conceded from set pieces yet where is the media frenzy about man marking?
Zonal marking has given Liverpool one of the best defensive records over the last five years so it's all nonsense.
If Fergie decided to use zonal marking it would be classed as a stroke of genius, this Rafa bashing from the media has go to stop.

Robbo said:

Spot on. And the sad thing is there's too many fans out there who take these so-called expert opinions as read and start regurgitating them and before you know it there's loads of 'em criticising the manager.

The fact is you don't go through a whole league campaign conceding just 27 goals if you don't know how to defend.

It's like another one of the myths, the whole 'two-man team' thing. Despite Johnson, Insua, Kuyt and Benayoun being in good form, it's trotted out week after week.

Have a look at my LFC blog:

http://www.robbohuyton.blogspot.com/

Cheers

Rich said:

We used zonal marking the season we had the best defense / least goals conceded/ most clean sheets. The pundits don't like it because it's not English, I suspect. Let's use some empiricism, please.

Red said:

The major problem with Liverpool's defence at the moment (in addition to new players bedding in) is Jamie Carragher - he looks past it this season.

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

October 2010

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31            

Liverpool FC video

The incomparable John Barnes

An Anfield legend at his peak

Keep up to date

Matches

Next Match

Bolton v Liverpool
Premier League
Sunday 31 October 16:00

View latest news here


Last Match

Liverpool 2, Blackburn 1
Premier League
Sun Oct 24

View our reports here

Liverpool Twitter

Twitter

Follow me on Twitter

Merseyshop

Liverpool fans read

Technorati

Blogs that link here

Add to Technorati Favorites

Sponsored Links