Have the Premiership Referees Got A Campaign Against Liverpool Football Club

By Faith Fulcher on Sep 11, 11 11:53 AM in Fans

We are all familiar with the stories surrounding Sir Alex Ferguson and how referees tend to give their decisions in his favour but as the game against Stoke unfolded yesterday it became clear that perhaps they also work in the opposite direction.

Liverpool was playing Stoke at the Britannia Stadium, a game which for 27 years they have not won, and it was always going to be hard.  Yesterday though, Stoke appeared to have the help of referee Mark Clattenberg, who had it transpired,  not refereed a premiership game for some time.  There were also questions being asked about the alteration to the pitch size and indeed the grass, which appeared to be longer than usual.

But all said and done it was the game where again the team selection seemed to be out of sync with the type of game in front of them. Everyone expected Andy Carroll to be in the starting line-up due to his size but Kenny chose the team that had won previously against Bolton.  His named bench though contained Coates and Bellamy which meant that if necessary he had experienced players to call upon if and when the game needed to change.

With the wind beginning to swirl around the stadium the game began and it looked as though Liverpool had the upper hand from the off.  The style of play was again the pass and move one which we have all come to enjoy since January and rings were beginning to be run around the Stoke players, so much so that it looked as though Liverpool's first goal of the afternoon was not too far away.

Then came the first of several questionable incidents, a penalty was given to Stoke by Mark Clattenberg, who appeared to indicate that Jamie had wrapped his arms around Jon Walters and impede his next move.  Now I was watching the game on a computer stream and I am sorry but what I saw was totally different.  Jamie went for the ball and seeing an easy scoring chance young Jon Walters did all he could to kid the referee and unfortunately it worked.  Stoke were now one up and it appeared to knock a slight bit of confidence out of the Liverpool players.  

The momentum they had built up seemed to be lost for the rest of the half, a half where there was a blatant hand ball but strangely this was missed by both the linesman and Mark Clattenburg.  Luis Suarez was also it appeared having one of those days, having tried not only to set up a couple of goals but to try scoring his own to no avail. 

Half time came and as the teams re-emerged for the second half, it was immediately evident that no changes had been made.  Kenny had decided to keep his faith in the lads on the pitch, after all there was still time to turn the game around.

In fact Liverpool had come out of the dressing room with more intent than in the first half.  They were quickly all over Stoke and the appeared to be in the Stoke half.  The determination to get the goal to pull us level was there, but it was just not going to happen and shortly after the sixty minute mark Kenny brought on Andy Carroll and Craig Bellamy for Dirk Kuyt and Jordan Henderson. 

The travelling over the last few weeks for the Dirk I suspect had taken their toll because he seemed out of sorts.  Jordan Henderson I am sure is quite ready yet to appear on the big stage week in and week out.  He seemed to appear anonymous for most of the game until he had several sitters saved by the Stoke goalkeeper.

 

Did Andy Carroll make a difference to the team, that I am not sure off.  Apart from one shot of the goal his game was still not as fluid as it should have been and to me from the moment Craig Bellamy came on the pitch, you could see the commitment and the passion in his play.  On another day I am sure he could have scored.

The game continued, but the goal was simply were not going to come.  Martin Skrtel, who Kenny decided to replace with Glen Johnson, even had a chance at the goal, but the kick was too hard and the ball flew straight over the goalpost.  Things then took a turn for the worst because his replacement, Glen Johnson, having only been on the pitch for a matter of minutes injured his hamstring once more.  This brings up another set of questions as to why he was passed fit in the first place, but that is a discussion for another day.

We then had another missed penalty situation.  There was clearly a handball in the goal area and once again this was missed by the linesman and Mark Clattenberg.  Luis Suarez, who can be very hot tempered went over and complained to the linesman and earned a yellow card for his trouble, which was totally wrong, because he only saw, we all did sitting at home.

After a further frantic ten minutes of play the game finished with Stoke winning and their 27 year old history intact.  It did though raise as I have said many questions about the refereeing of Liverpool games from the boss himself, Kenny Dalglish.

Now Kenny as we know, since his return has kept his feelings about the officials to himself, but I guess yesterday's blatant misses were the last straw.  In his post-match press conference, he did say that he could not understand why not only were the decisions today  given against us, but also in the previous three games. Decisions which we the supporter, know should have been made, having watched the events leading up to them unfold.

Kenny being a gentleman, rather than rant immediately, has said that he will speak to John Henry before making any comments to either Mike Riley from the Referees Association or indeed whether he should indeed make any comments to the referees in charge of our games in the future.  As he himself said, if those decisions impact on his football club, then something needs to be done.

Which of course it does, because these so-called top referees, are supposed to all go by the same rule book.  It should not matter whether they are refereeing Liverpool Football Club or Manchester United.  There should be no favouritism or indeed lack of respect for the team on the pitch.  They are there supposedly to ensure that fair play takes place, not to help the team of the moment to yet another premiership title. 

 

4 Comments

NickyL said:

Clearly was a penalty against Carra sorry but he's dragged him down, his legs have gone, second clean sheet he's cost Pepe and needs to be eased into management or coaching role now.


Not sure exactly what the talk with the owners will produce, their is an untouchable air about match officials and any criticism is going to mean a touchline ban regardless of how true it is, which is pathetic really.

They would just ignore any video evidence of poor decisions or bias, as I believe they did under Rafa's regime..

Clattenburg is a p***-poor referee who consistently shows bias to home teams though, not just against us, he would be better suited to officiating the Blue Square North.

I'm pleased with Kenny because he has been very restrained with the amount of anger he and we all have given the decisions going aginst us lately, very tactful of him.

nickyL said:

Clearly was a penalty against Carra sorry but he's dragged him down, his legs have gone, second clean sheet he's cost Pepe and needs to be eased into management or coaching role now.


Not sure exactly what the talk with the owners will produce, their is an untouchable air about match officials and any criticism is going to mean a touchline ban regardless of how true it is, which is pathetic really.

They would just ignore any video evidence of poor decisions or bias, as I believe they did under Rafa's regime..

Clattenburg is a p***-poor referee who consistently shows bias to home teams though, not just against us, he would be better suited to officiating the Blue Square North.

I'm pleased with Kenny because he has been very restrained with the amount of anger he and we all have given the decisions going aginst us lately, very tactful of him.

Angus said:

Been like this for years. Man U always get the decisions Pool get shafted. Imagine if that was Stoke vs Man U. They would have had 2 penalties and Stoke none. Fergie and Man U players been dominating refs for years.

Prudence said:

I bow down humbly in the peresnce of such greatness.

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Latest Premier League video

Get Adobe Flash player

Video

October 2011

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
            1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31          

Liverpool FC video

The incomparable John Barnes

An Anfield legend at his peak

Keep up to date

Matches

Next Match

Everton v Liverpool

Premier League
Sat 1 Oct 12:45

View latest news here


Last Match

Liverpool 2 Wolves 1
Premier League
Sat Sept 24

View our reports here

Liverpool Twitter

Twitter

Follow me on Twitter

Merseyshop

Liverpool fans read

Technorati

Blogs that link here

Add to Technorati Favorites

Sponsored Links