Luis Says Sorry But Mistakes Made By All Concerned May Mean That This Saga is Far From Over
On
the stroke of midnight on Wednesday the media released details of what would be
their lead story in the following morning's newspapers. Luis Suarez, it appeared had finally
apologised for the racist remark that
he 'uttered' towards Patrice Evra.
The
apology itself took the form of a public relations exercise rather than a
heartfelt one, directly aimed at Patrice Evra. Now I have no intention of
adding any further fuel to the fire but the circumstances surrounding the
situation surely should have deemed that it was televised, that way the player
would be witnessed saying the words below The most telling sentence of course
was this particular one.
"I
never, ever used the word in a derogatory way and if it offends anyone then I
want to apologise for that."
This
was followed by:
"I
admitted to the commission that I said a word in Spanish once, and only once,
and I told the panel members that I will not use it again on a football pitch
in England".
It
is hoped of course that those two sentences will begin to restore the
reputation of not only Luis Suarez, but that of Liverpool Football Club. Inwardly
I suspect, both know that there is a massive mountain to climb and it is going
to a lot of time and effort on the part of both.
Luis
of course will serve the remainder of his ban - he has a further 7 matches to
sit out and then he must begin the task of rebuilding his career - that is of
course, if he decides to stay in this country.
Over the last week there have been murmurings indicating that he may
consider going abroad because of the treatment dished out to him by the
Football Association and the media. It
would be a great loss to the Premier League and indeed Liverpool Football Club
if he chose to do this, but it would also be fully understandable.
Whatever
he decides to do or indeed wherever he goes, he must immerse himself completely
into fighting the bigotry that surrounds racism, be it through the community
schemes that he is already part off or indeed setting up a foundation that
would see him lecturing to people from all parts of the world.
Liverpool
Football Club has now conceded that they handled the situation wrong from the
moment, the complaint being made by Patrice Evra and Sir Alex Ferguson was
overheard by Mr.Haughan. Now I am no
public relations expert or indeed someone who is versed in the laws that
surround sport in this country, but it would have been better for all
concerned, once Liverpool had been informed of the situation by Mr Marriner, to
wait for a copy of his report before rushing in to defend their player. As we all know, in most situations, it is
better to think first, rather than rush in and get the wrong result.
And
get the wrong result they did, because Luis and his good name has been dragged
through the mud, due to his lack of understanding about the use of a word in
this country, a word it is understood, he uses daily at home, whilst talking
affectionately to his wife.
They
also showed their support for Luis by wearing t-shirts with his picture on the
front - whoever thought up that idea, was in my opinion not thinking
straight. That sort of act is better
left to the supporters. The players
should have just left it alone after making their feelings clear either on the
club's official website or indeed through the different social network sites
that they use. It certainly would have
stopped a lot of the adverse comments that became part of the media's match
reports the following day.
The
statements issued could have said essentially the same thing, but worded quite
differently. They should also have had a signature a bottom, to ensure that the
watching world knew they had come from the top.
This did not happen and has unfortunately opened up a further can of
worms. The media is quite rightly beginning to ask questions about the club's
ownership and they need to be nipped in the bud and very quickly. I know we have for all intents and purposes
returned the club to 'The Liverpool Way' of doing things, but sometimes the old
adage 'rules are made to be broken' comes into play and this is one of them.
The
Media have not come have also made some very bad mistakes since the 'verdict'
was announced. Headlines have been
written badly and articles have seemed to favour the Manchester United
viewpoint. I agree with the point about
the headlines, for the simple reason, I have made several complaints about them
myself. I did this of course through the
right channels, I did not go onto Twitter or Facebook and abuse those who may
or may not have written them. I got the responses I wanted and have accepted
their reasons. The articles have been
deemed as abusive and libellous because they have not been read properly -
people have seen the headline and not read or digested the article properly.ONE
THING I MUST POINT OUT IS, THE WRITER OF THE ARTICLE DOES NOT CHOSE THE
HEADLINE - THAT IS DONE BY THE HEADLINE EDITOR.
He chooses the one that he feels will sell the paper because they rely
on sensationalism and it has backfired spectacularly.
The
abuse aimed at journalists on Twitter has been unwarranted and needs to
stop. They write what information they
are given either by their contacts, from press releases by the club's press
department or indeed the weekly press conferences that they attend. They also write their own opinion pieces in
their respective papers. A lot of these
have been taken out of context. They are
after all, doing what we do, and that is putting their own feelings into print. There is nothing wrong with that, we live in
a country where free speech is allowed. They may not have felt the same way as
we do, but that is just the way it is.
It is just a great pity that those who feel they have a right to defend
their club, do it is such a way that any contact, we have with the media through
the social networking system, will soon be gone, because all they did was let's
face it, do what we all wanted to do and discuss the ongoing situation.
I
am sure that if the lines of communication between the club and the media had
been a lot more open than they have been, the situation would have been
reported and dealt with in a much better manner.
Now
to the Football Association, we all know that their investigation was flawed
from the moment it was set in motion but, at the moment, there is nothing, we
the supporters can do. We have to take a back seat here and wait for things to
happen. Because happen they will, they
will not come out of this as well as they believe they have. Questions will be asked by any club or player
ordered to go before a disciplinary committee.
No verdict will be seen as the correct one from now on. At some point in the future , the 115 page
report that was issued on New Years Eve, will be dismantled and the fallout
will be massive not only for them but for all those, who decided to ensure that
a grave miscarriage of justice would take place. They may not realise it now, but several
careers will be in ruins and quite rightly so of course.
The
government called for the FA to be dismantled last year and set up again with
people who have no allegiance to football at the helm. This now needs to happen
because until it does, even though they believe by reaching the verdict they
have, they have shown FIFA that they can run the game. Unfortunately they have done the exact
opposite. They have shown FIFA what an
inept organisation they are by not having the courage to do the right thing.
So
in a nutshell I have highlighted above what I feel to be major mistakes by the
agencies concerned. Mistakes that were
highlighted again this morning when the transcript of Sir Alex Fergusons Friday
press conference were released.
His
words were and I quote
"It's
nice of them to do it through the press"
"You
would have thought they would have come to Manchester United first"
"I
don't see why there is any need for that (peace talks) to be honest".
Liverpool
did indeed do it through the media last night to ensure it appeared in this
morning's papers, although I am sure and I sincerely hope that Liverpool's
press officer let Manchester United's press officer know what was being done. If not then serious questions need to be
asked.
Questions
that may ultimately lead to staff changes, because this whole affair has been
handled very badly, not only by them but also by their PR department. Better
lines of communication need to be opened up with the press - it is far better
to have friends in the media rather than enemies who desperate for a story will
print what snippets of information they get hold off, be it right or wrong.
A
statement needs to be issued by the owners.
This is quite possibly the only thing that will stop the alienation that
is growing between the media and certain sections of the supporters. It will also I hope stop the bridge the gap
that is beginning to appear between the club's supporters because of their
differing viewpoint.
Most
importantly, it may be the one thing that throws water onto the dying embers
that are still out there. If it does
not, then that fire is going to be re-ignited for the simple reason, this story
may well have a long way to go yet.
Racism
has been brought to the fore once more and we all need to ensure that it is
dealt with and discussed properly. The
one thing we must not do is ensure that the strides made to eradicate it over
the last fifty years have wasted.
Older/Newer
« Two Statements Issued, But Both Are Missing A Vital Word | Racism Comes Out of The Shadows Once Again »



As long as writers such as you keep on at it then you will be happy to keep it running as long as possible!We'll move on and you can catch up later...
I actually don't have a problem with this case going on. The longer it goes on, the more chance of people realizing it really isn't about racism at all. It's about how football is run in England. It's about player actions on and off the field. It's about the justice system that determines who's right and who's wrong.
We have to remember that at the very core of it, Suarez was not charged with racism, but rather bringing the game into disrepute. That the word he said was 'negro' just added fuel to the fire and enabled a further charge of making reference to race. In essence what this case is telling us is that even if Suarez had said something completely neutral like 'friend', or 'pal', and Evra felt it was done in aggression, that would be enough to have him convicted. That's what the base charge is all about.
This case is about one man's word against another and the judicial system that, in the absence of any conclusive evidence, decides who to believe and who to condemn. If you expand it, it could have been an accusation of Suarez saying or doing anything at any time. It could have been an altercation in the tunnel where Evra accuses Suarez of showing him the finger but no one else saw it. It could be at a local club with Evra accusing Suarez of hitting him as they bumped into each other in the bathroom. Essentially it's an accusation made with no substantial evidence other than the word of the accuser, and yet the justice system that the FA employs allows for a conclusive guilty verdict to be passed. There is no court in the land that would accept anything of the sort.
If this saga drags on, it certainly wouldn't be the best for LFC or Suarez. But if people can get past the racism aspect and see the case for what it is, I think it'll do English football a world of good.
I actually don't have a problem with this case going on. The longer it goes on, the more chance of people realizing it really isn't about racism at all. It's about how football is run in England. It's about player actions on and off the field. It's about the justice system that determines who's right and who's wrong.
We have to remember that at the very core of it, Suarez was not charged with racism, but rather bringing the game into disrepute. That the word he said was 'negro' just added fuel to the fire and enabled a further charge of making reference to race. In essence what this case is telling us is that even if Suarez had said something completely neutral like 'friend', or 'pal', and Evra felt it was done in aggression, that would be enough to have him convicted. That's what the base charge is all about.
This case is about one man's word against another and the judicial system that, in the absence of any conclusive evidence, decides who to believe and who to condemn. If you expand it, it could have been an accusation of Suarez saying or doing anything at any time. It could have been an altercation in the tunnel where Evra accuses Suarez of showing him the finger but no one else saw it. It could be at a local club with Evra accusing Suarez of hitting him as they bumped into each other in the bathroom. Essentially it's an accusation made with no substantial evidence other than the word of the accuser, and yet the justice system that the FA employs allows for a conclusive guilty verdict to be passed. There is no court in the land that would accept anything of the sort.
If this saga drags on, it certainly wouldn't be the best for LFC or Suarez. But if people can get past the racism aspect and see the case for what it is, I think it'll do English football a world of good.
It's about time someone said it, so here goes.
Racism is here to stay.
It will never go away.
As long as we persist with multi culturism, problems will arise.
It is the the clash of cultures that is the fire starter.
People of different colour can live happily alongside each other as long as they live by the same rules.
Unfortunately, in Britain this is not the case.
Racism in this country is similar to health and safety at work, both go O.T.T.
This writer surely is not Liverpool so never mind his naive opinion.
Geez, that's ubneleivable. Kudos and such.
Right you are Tom! Also tanks to the author. I am not sure why Nyathi mention that the writer is not Liverpool.